The short answer
It’s usually one of five things: visitors are the wrong audience, the page doesn’t say clearly what you do and for whom, the next step is hard to find or too much effort, the site doesn’t earn trust, or it’s slow or awkward on a phone. Check them in that order — and check your tracking isn’t missing enquiries — before paying for a redesign.
In this guide
A website that attracts visitors but not enquiries is frustrating, because the expensive part — getting people there — seems to be working. The good news is that the fix is often smaller than a new website.
First, make sure enquiries aren’t just going uncounted
Check that form submissions reach you and are recorded, that phone calls from the website are tracked, and that email clicks count. A broken form or untracked calls can make a working site look like a failing one. What to measure in your marketing explains how to check.
1. Are they the right visitors?
Traffic numbers mean little if the visitors were never going to buy. Look at:
- Where they come from — search, ads, social or referral sites
- What they searched for. Google Search Console, which is free, shows the searches that bring people to your site.
- Where they are, if you only serve some areas
- Which pages they land on — a blog post that attracts students won’t produce customer enquiries
If most visitors are the wrong audience, that’s a marketing problem rather than a website problem. See why your marketing isn’t bringing in enough enquiries.
2. Can a visitor tell what you do in a few seconds?
People decide quickly whether they’re in the right place. The top of each key page should answer three questions without scrolling:
- What do you do? In plain words, not a slogan.
- Who is it for, and where?
- Why you? One concrete reason — experience, speed, price, speciality.
A useful test: show the page to someone who doesn’t know your business for five seconds, then ask what you sell.
3. Is the next step obvious and easy?
- One clear main action per page — call, book, request a quote — repeated where it makes sense
- A phone number people can tap on mobile, if calls matter to you
- Forms that ask only for what you need to reply; every extra field loses some people
- Some sense of price, where you can give it. “From…” prices or typical ranges help people decide to get in touch
- Clear expectations: “We’ll reply within one working day”
4. Does the page earn trust?
Visitors are checking whether you’re real, competent and safe to contact. Help them with:
- Genuine reviews, especially recent ones, and examples of your work
- Real photos of your team, premises or projects rather than stock images
- Accreditations, memberships or guarantees that mean something in your sector
- A clear address or service area, and full contact details
5. Does it work on a phone?
Many visitors will arrive on a mobile. Open your key pages on your own phone, on mobile data rather than office wi-fi, and try to enquire. Check that text is readable, buttons are easy to tap and nothing jumps around as it loads. Google’s free PageSpeed Insights tool highlights speed problems.
Fix, rebuild or leave it?
Most of the issues above can be fixed on your existing site: clearer copy, a simpler form, better proof, faster images. A rebuild is worth considering when the site can’t be edited, doesn’t work properly on mobile, runs on an unsupported platform, or no longer fits what the business does.
Before paying for a new website, fix the message and the next step — they carry across to any new design anyway. For help deciding, see web design advice or, if you’re weighing up a builder such as Squarespace or Wix against an agency, website builder advice.
A quick self-audit
- Enquiry tracking tested and working
- The right visitors, from the right searches and places
- What you do, for whom and why you — visible without scrolling
- One obvious next step, easy on mobile
- Short form, visible phone number, reply-time expectation
- Genuine reviews and real photos
- Fast and readable on a phone
What to do next
- Test your forms and calls and confirm every enquiry is recorded.
- Check the searches and places your visitors come from.
- Rewrite the top of your main pages to say what you do, for whom and why you.
- Simplify the next step and try it yourself on a phone.
Apply this to your business
Find what’s stopping your website converting
Tell askBizly where visitors come from and what happens on the site. It works out the likely causes and gives you a prioritised list of fixes, including which you can do yourself.
Free to use. Create a free account when you want to save your plan and come back to it.